Amazon Consultant vs Agency: Which Should You Hire?

A consultant from Amazon says that they identify the problems, draw up a strategy and train your team, generally on an hourly basis or per project. An Amazon agency, on the other hand, carries out the day-to-day management of your advertising, listings and account for a monthly fee. You should employ a consultant if you already have people who can carry out the work and merely need some guidance. You should choose an agency if no one has the time to carry out the work.

Key takeaways

  • The actual difference lies in who carries out the work. A consultant gives you advice about what changes to make; it is the agency that carries out the changes. Most poor hiring decisions are the result of expecting a consultant to carry out execution or expecting an agency — which only carries out execution — to provide strategy.

  • Although consultants are cheaper on a monthly basis they don't necessarily cost less in total; a senior consultant earning between $80 and $140 per hour for eight hours a month amounts to $640 to $1,120, it still having to be your own team who carry out the work.

  • Although agencies are more expensive they do include the labour; typical monthly retainers for mid-market agencies range from $3,000 to $7,500 and cover advertising, listings, reporting and account health.

  • The title of 'consultant' isn't subject to regulation and so anyone can call themselves one. To find out what the person has actually done, check their activities on sites such as yours.

  • Many brands carry out the two steps in turn: they first get an audit or a consultant to identify the problems, and then employ an agency or their own team to deal with them.

What is the difference between an Amazon agency and an Amazon consultant?

An Amazon consultant is typically a specialist who gives advice on strategy, identifies problems with the account and trains your team, while it is your staff who carry out the changes. An Amazon agency on the other hand is a company which has a team that looks after the account for you by running the campaigns, editing the listings, dealing with cases from Seller or Vendor Support and then reporting the results each month.

Amazon consultant Amazon agency
Main role Advise, diagnose, plan, train Execute and manage day to day
Who does the work Your team The agency's team
Typical pricing Hourly, per project, or a small advisory retainer Monthly retainer, sometimes plus % of sales or ad spend
Typical commitment One project or a few hours a month Ongoing, often month to month or 3–12 month contracts
Skills covered Deep in one or two areas Several areas: ads, listings, creative, inventory, account health, reporting
Continuity Depends on one person Team covers holidays and staff changes
Access to your account Often read-only or none Usually user permissions to make changes
Accountability For the quality of the advice For results and the work done
Best for Brands with an in-house team that needs direction, or a one-off problem Brands without the time or people to run Amazon

The boundary isn't always clear-cut. In some cases consultants also carry out the work, and other agencies provide standalone audit or strategy projects. You should ask each of them directly, 'Who is going to implement the changes in my account and who will be responsible if there is no improvement in the results?'

What is the cost of an Amazon consultant when compared to that of an agency?

According to goLance's 2026 rate guide (September 2026) freelance Amazon specialists charge between $20 an hour at the junior level and between $140 and $225 for experts who have 10 or more years' experience. Monthly retainers for mid-market Amazon agencies generally amount to $3,000 to $7,500. The consultant is less expensive on a monthly basis since the agency includes the labour.

Consultant rates by experience (goLance, worldwide freelance market, 2026):

Experience Hourly rate
Junior (0–2 years) $20–$40
Mid-level (2–5 years) $40–$80
Senior (5–10 years) $80–$140
Expert (10+ years, niche) $140–$225

Marketplace listings are often considerably lower. For example, Fiverr lists campaign management jobs at a rate of $10 to $65 per hour and fixed-price audits at a price of about $35 to $166 (Fiverr, August 2026). At these prices you are getting a checklist, not a senior diagnosis for a seven-figure account.

What does each option really cost per month? A worked example

The comparison takes into account the amount of time your own team spends carrying out the work that a consultant suggests. For example, there is a particular brand that requires a strategy along with about 40 hours each month of direct work (such as campaign changes, listing edits, reports, and support cases). The assumptions are clearly labelled so that you can replace them with your own.

Option A: senior consultant + your team

  • Consultant: 8 hours a month × $110 (mid-point of goLance's senior range) = $880

  • Your team's execution: 40 hours × [NEEDS: your internal hourly cost; $45 used here as an illustration] = $1,800

  • Total: about $2,680 a month, plus the management time to coordinate the two

Option B: agency

  • Retainer covering strategy and execution: $3,000–$7,500 a month (mid-market range; fees vary by scope and account size)

  • Your team's time: a monthly review call and approvals, a few hours

What the comparison shows:

  • If you already have someone capable who has some free time, then taking the consultant approach will be cheaper and ensures that the skills remain within the organisation.

  • If the 40 hours were provided by a founder or a hard-pressed marketer, then the actual cost of choosing Option A would be the work that had to be left undone—such is the way in which the agency ends up paying for itself.

  • When multiple skills are required (for example, those relating to ads and creative and Vendor Central deductions), a single consultant is usually unable to deal with all of them, and in this case the agency's range of skills is more important than its price.

At what stage should you employ an Amazon consultant?

You should get an Amazon consultant if you have people who are capable of carrying out the work but who need expert guidance, or if you have a particular problem that has to be solved within a fixed time frame. Consultants are most suitable for carrying out audits, for reviewing and reworking a strategy, for launches, for training an employee you have hired yourself, and for specialist matters where you would like an independent second opinion.

Good reasons to hire a consultant:

  • You need a senior adviser who is already part of the company’s Amazon management team, not someone to take their place.

  • You'll need a one-off diagnosis, for example, 'Why has sales dropped by 30%?' or 'Is our PPC structure wasting money?'

  • You want to launch on Amazon and are looking for a plan that your team will carry out.

  • If you want to have your agency examined independently, then a consultant can check whether the agency's work and reports are up to the mark.

  • In order for your team to manage the account themselves, you'll need to provide them with some training.

When a consultant is the wrong choice:

  • There isn't anyone on your team who can find time to carry out the recommendations.

  • The account has to be looked at every day (with regard to the ads, the stock, and account health monitoring).

  • It involves a wide range of skills simultaneously.

At what point should you employ an Amazon agency?

You should engage an Amazon agency whenever the account requires continuous, direct management in a number of different areas and there is no one within the company who has the time to look after it; agencies are suitable for brands for whom Amazon is a significant channel, where the founder or marketing lead is busy, and the tasks involve advertising, listings, inventory, account health and reporting.

Good reasons to hire an agency:

  • A number of jobs are now lagging behind and no one has ownership of the Amazon account.

  • The amount spent on advertising is so great that daily adjustments have an impact on the results.

  • Continuity is necessary since the account would have to break if one person goes on holiday.

  • If you are selling through Vendor Central then you will need a person to look after your purchase orders, deductions and disputes on a continuing basis.

  • What you need is a single accountable partner rather than having to co-ordinate a number of freelancers.

Whether to choose a consultant or an agency depends on your particular situation.

Your situation Best fit Why
In-house manager who needs direction Consultant You pay for expertise, not labor you already have
Sales dropped and you don't know why Consultant or an agency audit A diagnosis first, before committing to ongoing fees
Nobody has time to run Amazon Agency The work needs doing, not just planning
Big ad budget, daily optimization needed Agency Constant hands-on management
New brand launching on Amazon Consultant for the plan, then agency or in-house to execute Strategy first, execution after
Vendor Central deductions piling up Agency with Vendor Central experience Ongoing disputes need someone working them weekly
You want to check your current agency's work Independent consultant A second opinion with no stake in the answer

How do you vet an Amazon consultant or agency?

Check their credentials on the basis of evidence rather than just their titles; request information about accounts similar to yours, a sample report, who exactly will be carrying out the work, and what access they will require. Since anyone can refer to themselves as an Amazon consultant, you should verify their experience with your marketplace, your selling model (Seller or Vendor Central) and your category.

Questions to ask both:

  1. What results have you obtained for companies such as ours? Request the specific figures along with the time period and the method used to measure them.

  2. As to who is actually going to work on my account, get some names and look into their experience, not just the founder's background.

  3. The level of access you require is such that having read-only access for the purpose of an audit is a positive indication. It is important not to share your owner login details; instead use the user permissions available in Seller Central.

  4. What should you do when reporting the results? Then request a sample report and find out the method they use to calculate the figures.

  5. What will occur when we stop collaborating? Ensure that the campaigns, the data and the creative remain yours.

For a consultant, an additional question is:this person's recommendations — who is responsible for carrying them out and will you then check the implementation?

For the agency, here's an extra question: "What is the notice period and are there any exit fees?"
The following are red flags in both cases: guaranteed rankings or sales figures, requests for your primary login details, vague explanations as to who carries out the work, and long contracts before any audit. 

Can an Amazon consultant and an agency be used together?

Yes, a typical arrangement is for there to be a consultant or an in-house manager responsible for strategy, while an agency handles the execution. This setup works if the responsibilities are put in writing — for example, specifying who decides on budgets, who approves changes to the listings, and who is in charge of reporting. It fails, however, when both sides make changes to the same campaigns or listings, or when no one is clearly accountable for the results.

Two models that work well:

  • Carry out the audit first. The independent audit should detect the problems, after which the agency (or your team) will deal with them, using the audit results as the standard for future comparison.

  • The strategy will be led by a senior consultant or someone who is an in-house lead on a quarterly basis, while the agency looks after the account from day to day and keeps track of the objectives.

How JumpStart Audits works: audit first, then execution

JumpStart Audits uses both approaches. Each engagement begins with an account audit, which is carried out using only read-access and shows you what costs you money before you agree to anything. If you wish for JSA to carry out the work, it will manage your Seller Central and Vendor Central accounts with a dedicated account manager on a month-to-month basis without charging any exit fees, and any changes will require your approval.

Results from JSA-managed accounts:

  • The efficiency of advertising decreased from 9.06 to 6.56% over a period of two months, although sales increased by 1.03% and the number of units went up by 3.78%.

  • As a result of Amazon applying a co-op rate increase that the brand had not approved, $110,000 was recovered through Vendor Central.

Book a free audit to see what your account needs before deciding who should do the work.

Questions brands ask about Amazon consultants and agencies

Is an Amazon consultant less expensive than an agency?

Most months, yes: the cost for a senior consultant for a few hours each month is a few hundred dollars to about a thousand dollars, as compared to $3,000 to $7,500 for a retainer from a mid-market agency. However, the consultant's fee does not cover implementation; when you add in the time that your own team spends on the work, the difference is often considerably reduced.

Do the Amazon consultants look after the account themselves?

While some people do, the majority of consultants just offer advice and it's your team that carries out the work. If you require someone to carry out daily changes in Seller Central or Vendor Central, make sure this is included before you hire and get it in writing. When a consultant is responsible for carrying out the work, they are in effect running a one-person agency, together with the continuity risks that entails.

What exactly does an Amazon consultant provide?

Usually the output will include an audit report, a strategy or action plan, recommendations concerning advertising and listings, and training or regular advisory calls. It is advisable to request a sample deliverable prior to employing someone. A helpful audit should identify specific problems, provide estimates of their costs and rank the remedies according to their impact.

For how long should you work with an Amazon consultant?

It is normal to have a single project lasting a few weeks as part of a diagnosis or a launch plan. For providing continuous advice to an in-house team, spending a few hours each month on a rolling basis is adequate. However, if you find that you have to consult the consultant every week in order to keep everything running, then you probably should consider hiring an agency or employing someone full-time in-house.

Can an Amazon consultant provide assistance in the case of an account suspension?

A few focus on appeals and account health, in which case a specialist consultant is superior to a generalist agency; check their history of account reinstatements and make sure you never give out your owner login details. 

Previous
Previous

Late Shipment Rate and Valid Tracking Rate: The Fulfillment Metrics That Quietly Trigger Amazon Suspensions

Next
Next

What Is Amazon's Account Health Rating (AHR), and How Is It Actually Calculated?