Questions to Ask Before Hiring an Amazon Agency (and Red Flags)

Before hiring an Amazon agency, ask 12 questions across five areas: proof of results, who does the work, account access, pricing and contract terms, and policy compliance. The biggest red flags are guaranteed sales or rankings, a request for your Seller Central password, a 12-month lock-in, and reports you cannot check against your own account.

Key takeaways

  • Judge an Amazon agency by what it can show inside an account, with date ranges, and not by what it promises on a sales call.

  • Never share your Seller Central password. Amazon's own guidance is to invite users and grant the minimum permissions they need.

  • Pricing tied to ad spend rewards the agency for spending more. Ask how the fee changes if spend goes up and profit does not.

  • Read the exit terms before the scope: notice period, auto-renewal, exit fees, and who keeps the campaigns, creative and data.

  • JumpStart Audits is an Amazon agency, so this guide ends with our own answers to the same questions.

What questions should you ask before hiring an Amazon agency?

Ask an Amazon agency 12 questions before you sign: three on proof, two on the team, two on account access, three on pricing and contract terms, and two on compliance and reporting. For each question, decide in advance what a good answer sounds like, so a confident sales call cannot stand in for evidence.

# Question to ask A good answer A red flag
1 Can you show results from an account like mine, with date ranges? Anonymised before-and-after figures with the comparison periods stated Per cent gains with no baseline, period or category
2 Can I speak to two current clients and one former client? Yes, with contact details within a few days Only written testimonials, or "our clients are confidential"
3 What would you change first in my account, and why? Specific findings from an audit of your data A fixed package pitched before anyone has looked at the account
4 Who will work on my account day to day, and how many brands do they manage? Named people you meet before signing, with a stated workload You only ever meet the salesperson
5 Is any work outsourced or handed to contractors? A clear list of what is in-house and what is not Vague answers, or a different team after onboarding
6 How will you access my Seller Central or Vendor Central account? Invited user access with limited permissions, starting read-only "Just send us your login"
7 Will I keep admin access to my Amazon Ads account and see every campaign? Yes. You own the ad account, and they are a user on it Campaigns run in an account the agency controls
8 What is the fee, and what is it calculated on? One written formula, with an example at your current sales and ad spend A fee that rises with ad spend and no cap or profit target
9 What is the contract length, notice period and renewal rule? Month-to-month or a short term, with 30 days' notice 12 months, auto-renewal, 90 days' notice
10 What do I keep if we part ways? Campaigns, listing copy, creative files, reports and keyword research "Our proprietary structure stays with us"
11 How do you get reviews and rank for a new product? Amazon Vine, advertising and listing work Review groups, rebates for reviews, or "we have a method"
12 What will I receive each week and month, and can I verify it? Reports that match the numbers in your own Seller Central and Amazon Ads console Screenshots and blended metrics you cannot reproduce

What are the biggest red flags when hiring an Amazon agency?

The seven biggest red flags when hiring an Amazon agency are guaranteed results, a request for your password, a long lock-in contract, fees tied only to ad spend, a package sold before an audit, results you cannot verify, and review tactics the agency will not explain. Any one of them is reason to pause; two is reason to walk away.

  1. Guaranteed sales, rankings or ACOS. No agency controls Amazon's search algorithm, competitor pricing or your inventory. A guarantee is a sales tactic.

  2. "Send us your login." Amazon's guidance to sellers is "Don't share your password with other people." An agency that asks for it is either careless or unfamiliar with how Amazon access works.

  3. A 12-month contract with auto-renewal. A long-term contract protects the agency's revenue, not your results. If a term is required, it should come with a performance review and an exit clause.

  4. Fees based only on ad spend. The agency earns more when you spend more, whether or not profit follows.

  5. A package before an audit. A proposal written without reading your account data is a template.

  6. Results with no baseline. "Sales up 200%" means nothing without the starting figure, the period and the ad spend behind it.

  7. Evasive answers on reviews. Buying or incentivising reviews breaks United States law and puts your listing at risk. See the compliance section below.

How should an Amazon agency access your Seller Central account?

An Amazon agency should access your Seller Central account as an invited user with limited permissions, never through your own login. You stay the primary user, you choose what the agency can see and edit, and you can remove the access in minutes. Read-only access is enough for an audit.

Amazon's seller guidance on user permissions gives three rules that apply directly to agencies (Amazon Seller Forums, "Seller Account User Permissions"):

  • "Don't share your password with other people."

  • "Grant the minimum permissions required for them to do their job."

  • "Regularly review the permissions granted to your users."

The same guidance tells sellers to connect outside service providers as authorised partners, not as regular staff users.

Amazon Ads works the same way. The advertiser invites the agency as a user with Admin, Editor or Viewer permissions, or approves a link request from the agency's manager account. Editor access is usually enough to run campaigns (Leadsie walkthrough, October 2, 2026). The ad account, its campaign history and its billing stay yours.

Permissions to keep to yourself: bank and payment settings, user management, and tax information.

How JumpStart Audits handles access: every JumpStart Audits engagement starts with read-only access for the audit. Edit permissions are added only for the services you approve, and nothing in the account changes without your sign-off.

How much does an Amazon agency cost, and which pricing model is safest?

Amazon agencies charge in four ways: a flat monthly retainer, a percentage of ad spend, a percentage of revenue, or a hybrid. A flat retainer or a hybrid with a profit-based threshold is safest for most brands because the fee doesn't rise just because the agency spent more of your money.

The ranges below are estimates published by the agency SupplyKick in September 2026, not an independent survey. Treat them as a starting point for comparing quotes (SupplyKick, "Amazon agency pricing").

Pricing model Published range What the agency is rewarded for Question to ask
Flat monthly retainer $1,500 to $25,000+ per month Keeping you as a client What exactly is in scope, and what costs extra?
Percentage of ad spend 10% to 20% of monthly ad spend Higher ad spend Is there a fee cap or a TACoS target?
Percentage of revenue 3% to 10% of Amazon revenue Higher total sales, including sales you would have made anyway Is the fee on total revenue or on growth above a baseline?
Hybrid Lower retainer plus a percentage above a sales threshold Growth above the threshold How is the threshold set, and when is it reviewed?

TACoS is total advertising cost of sales: ad spend divided by total revenue, including organic sales. It shows whether advertising is growing the whole business. ACOS, advertising cost of sales, only compares ad spend to ad-attributed sales.

What contract terms should you check before signing with an Amazon agency?

Check six terms in an Amazon agency contract before you sign: length, notice period, renewal, exit fees, ownership of work, and offboarding. These terms decide what leaving costs, and that cost is what you are really agreeing to.

  • Length. Month-to-month is the lowest risk. If the agency needs a minimum term to cover onboarding, 90 days is easier to justify than 12 months.

  • Notice period. 30 days is reasonable. 90 days means you pay for three more months after you decide to leave.

  • Renewal. Look for auto-renewal clauses and the date by which you must cancel.

  • Exit fees. Ask for the total cost of leaving in month four, in writing.

  • Ownership. The contract should say that campaigns, listing copy, images, A+ Content, Brand Store pages and reports belong to you.

  • Offboarding. Ask what the agency hands over, in what format, and how quickly its access is removed.

How JumpStart Audits handles contracts: JumpStart Audits works month to month, with no lock-ins and no hidden exit fees. The work has to earn the next month.

How do you verify an Amazon agency's results before you hire it?

Verify an Amazon agency's results in four steps: ask for an audit of your own account, ask for case studies with baselines and dates, call references, and check the agency's listing in the Amazon Ads partner directory. An agency that is good at the work can show it in your data before you pay.

  1. Ask for an audit first. An audit shows how the agency thinks and whether it found anything you did not already know. Give read-only access only.

  2. Ask for the baseline behind every number. A usable case study states the starting figure, the end figure, both periods and the account type.

  3. Call a former client. Ask why they left and how the handover went.

  4. Look the agency up in the Amazon Ads partner directory. Amazon Ads says partners earn Advanced or Verified status by demonstrating expertise and delivering results for advertisers (Amazon Ads Partner Network). A listing shows the agency meets Amazon Ads' criteria. It does not predict results for your account.

Can an Amazon agency's tactics put your account at legal or policy risk?

Yes. An Amazon agency acts under your account and your brand name, so its shortcuts become your exposure. The clearest example is reviews: in the United States, a Federal Trade Commission rule has prohibited buying or faking reviews since October 21, 2024, and hiring an agency does not move that risk off the brand.

The Federal Trade Commission's Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule bans fake reviews, reviews paid for on condition of a positive or negative rating, and undisclosed insider reviews. The FTC states that advertising agencies and reputation management companies "are not immune from liability under the rule" and that a business can be liable for buying reviews it knew, or should have known, were false. Courts can impose civil penalties for knowing violations (FTC, Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers).

How does JumpStart Audits answer these questions?

JumpStart Audits is an Amazon agency for Seller Central and Vendor Central brands, so the same test applies to us. We start with an audit under read-only access, work month to month with no lock-ins and no exit fees, and publish results with baselines and date ranges.

Question JumpStart Audits' answer
How do you access my account? Read-only access to start. Nothing changes without your approval.
What is the contract? Month-to-month. No lock-ins and no hidden exit fees.
What do you do first? A full account audit, then a strategy built on what it finds.
Can you show results with baselines? Advertising client: TACoS fell from 9.06% to 6.56%, June to August 2026 against March to May 2026. Full-service client: ad sales rose 74.8%, and ACOS fell from 29.9% to 21.5% over 15 months. Vendor Central client: $110,000 recovered in chargebacks. Individual results vary.

Book a free 20-minute strategy call and bring this list.

Questions sellers also ask about hiring an Amazon agency

Should you sign a 12-month contract with an Amazon agency?

A 12-month contract with an Amazon agency is rarely necessary. Month-to-month terms keep the agency accountable every month. If you accept a fixed term in exchange for a lower fee, add a 90-day performance review and the right to leave if agreed targets are missed.

How long does an Amazon agency take to show results?

Advertising changes usually show first, because bids and wasted spend can be fixed in weeks. Listing and organic ranking work takes longer. In one JumpStart Audits advertising account, TACoS fell from 9.06% to 6.56% across a three-month comparison period. Ask each agency what it expects to change in the first 30, 60 and 90 days.

What extra questions should Vendor Central brands ask an agency?

Vendor Central brands, which sell wholesale to Amazon as first-party vendors, should ask whether the agency audits chargebacks and co-op deductions against the signed vendor agreement, and who handles purchase orders and EDI compliance. Many agencies only manage advertising. JumpStart Audits recovered $110,000 for one vendor by reconciling deductions against the agreement.

Is an Amazon agency better than a freelancer or an in-house hire?

An agency suits brands that need several skills at once, such as advertising, listings, inventory and account health. A freelancer suits one clearly defined job, such as PPC management. An in-house hire suits brands with enough Amazon revenue to justify a full salary and the management time. The 12 questions above apply to all three.

What access should you never give an Amazon agency?

Never give an Amazon agency your primary login, your two-step verification codes, or permission to change bank and payment settings. Give invited-user access with only the permissions the work needs, and review that access every quarter.

When should you hire an Amazon agency?

Hire an Amazon agency when the account needs more skills than your team has time for, and when mistakes in advertising, inventory or account health already cost more than the fee would. If only one job is falling behind, such as PPC, a freelancer or a single in-house hire is usually the cheaper first step.

What should an Amazon agency report on?

An Amazon agency should report on profit as well as sales: revenue, ad spend, ACOS, TACoS, net margin, inventory position and account health. Every figure should be traceable to an export from your own Seller Central or Amazon Ads account. JumpStart Audits recomputes each reported number from the raw export and attaches a verification log.

Next
Next

Amazon Agency Pricing Models Explained